Santa Maria Antiqua Sarcophagus

Early Christian Art Borrows Forms from Roman (Pagan) Art

This third century sarcophagus (figure 1) from the Church of Santa Maria was undoubtedly made to serve as the tomb of a relatively prosperous third century Christian. As we will see below, Early Christian art borrowed many forms from pagan art.

The sarcophagus has an intricately carved exterior; the visible side depicts three distinct Christian scenes: the philosopher, Jonah, and the Good Shepherd. Each will be explored below.

Figure 1. Sarcophagus in the Church of Santa Maria Antiqua (Rome)

The male philosopher type that we see in figure 2 is easily identifiable with the same type in another third century sarcophagus, but in this case a non-Christian one.

The left image shows a standing female figure appears next to a seated, bearded male figure holding a scroll. The right figure shows a seated beard male figure writing while surrounded by other standing individuals.

Figure 2. (left) Santa Maria Antiqua Sarcophagus; (right) 3rd century non-Christian sarcophagus

A painting of Dioscorides being inspired by a muse

Figure 3. Dioscorides and a muse

The female figure beside him who holds her arms outstretched combines two different conventions. The outstretched hands in Early Christian art represent the so-called orant or praying figure. This is the same gesture found in the catacomb paintings of Jonah being vomited from the great fish, the Hebrews in the Furnace, and Daniel in the Lions den.

The juxtaposition of this female figure with the philosopher figure associates her with the convention of the muse, or source of inspiration for the philosopher. This convention is illustrated in a later sixth century miniature showing the figure of Dioscorides, an ancient Greek physician, pharmacologist, and botanist (figure 3).

In the left side of the sarcophagus, Jonah is represented sleeping under the ivy after being vomited from the great fish, shown on the left. The pose of the reclining Jonah with his arm over his head is based on the Greek (pagan) mythological figure of Endymion, whose wish to sleep for ever—and thus become ageless and immortal—explains the popularity of this subject on non-Christian sarcophagi (see figure 4 for a comparison).

The pose of both Jonah and Endymion is nearly identical, with both stretched out on the ground, leaning on their left arms with their right over their head. Jonah is surrounded by the ship and ivy, while Endymion is surrounded by other figures from his myth.

Figure 4. (left) Jonah sleeping under the ivy; (right) Endymion wishing for sleep

This portion of the sarcophagus features a young shepherd with a sheep held over his shoulders, its forelegs on one side of his neck and its hindlegs on the other. In this carving portion an older man is pointing at the shepherd and seemingly talking to his son about the shepherd.

Figure 5. “The Good Shepherd” from the Santa Maria Antiqua sarcophagus

On the right hand side of the Santa Maria Antiqua sarcophagus, another popular Early Christian image appears, known as the Good Shepherd (see figure 5). While echoing the New Testament parable of the Good Shepherd and the Psalms of David, the motif had clear parallels in Greek and Roman art, going back at least to Archaic Greek art, as exemplified by the so-called Moschophoros, or calf-bearer, from the early sixth century BCE (see figure 6).

Greek statue of a young man with a calf slung over his shoulders in the same manner depicted in “the good shepherd.”

Figure 6. Moschophoros, or calf-bearer

On the very right appears an image of the Baptism of Christ. The inclusion of this relatively rare representation of Christ probably refers to the importance of the sacrament of Baptism, which signified death and rebirth into a new Christian life.

A curious detail about the male and female figures at the center of the Santa Maria Antiqua sarcophagus is that their faces are unfinished. This suggests that this tomb was not made with a specific patron in mind. Rather, it was fabricated on a speculative basis, with the expectation that a patron would buy it and have his and presumably his wife’s likenesses added. If this is true, it says a lot about the nature of the art industry and the status of Christianity at this period. To produce a sarcophagus like this meant a serious commitment on the part of the maker. The expense of the stone and the time taken to carve it were considerable. A craftsman would not have made a commitment like this without a sense of certainty that someone would purchase it.