Module 3 Discussion: Critical Reading

In this discussion, you will apply your understanding of genres by reflecting on one you know well. After reading Kerry Dirk’s essay “Navigating Genres”, consider how the author uses various examples to illustrate how genres function and adapt based on purpose and audience.

Discussion Instructions

STEP 1: Carefully read the essay “Navigating Genres by Kerry Dirk. As you read, take notes on how Dirk defines and explains genres. Pay attention to the examples used and how genres can change depending on their context, audience, and purpose. Consider these questions as you read:

  • How does Dirk emphasize the importance of understanding genre expectations?
  • Toward the end of the essay, Dirk writes a ransom note in three different styles. Which version is the best fit for the “ransom note genre”?
  • What other insights from the reading stood out to you?

STEP 2: Think about genres you encounter regularly in your life. These could be written, spoken, visual, or digital formats. Some examples might include romance novels, superhero movies, funny TikToks or Reels, angry text messages, instruction manuals, or fantasy video games. Each of these genres has distinct characteristics that shape how they are created and interpreted.

Choose one genre that you feel familiar with and that you can analyze in detail.

STEP 3: Create a list of at least five characteristics or features that are commonly found in this genre. Consider aspects like tone and style, purpose, audience, structure and format, and language and word choice.

STEP 4: Write a 250-word reflection responding to the following prompts:

  • What do you think is a good example of your chosen genre? Explain why this example stands out.
  • How does this example demonstrate the five features you identified? Provide specific details to support your points.
  • Why do you think these features make the example successful within its genre?

Post your reflection, along with your list of five characteristics, to the discussion board.

STEP 5: After posting your reflection, read and respond to two classmates’ posts. Each response should be at least 75 words. Consider using these prompts to guide your responses:

  • How does your experience with genres relate to your classmate’s? Have you encountered a similar genre, or do you see any parallels between their genre and one you’re familiar with? Reflect on how your perspectives are similar or different.
  • What additional questions do you have about their genre or their example?

Be respectful and thoughtful in your responses. Avoid repeating what others have said—provide specific feedback, new insights, or a different perspective to engage in a meaningful conversation.

Rubric

Sample Grading Rubric
Criteria Proficient Developing Not Evident Points
Follows prompt directions Follows the prompt instructions. Somewhat follows the prompt instructions. Examples may incomplete. Does not follow the instructions. __/10
Responds to peers Response is engaged with peer’s post. Posts on time. Response is somewhat engaged with peer’s post. Post is short and/or late. Does not follow the instructions. __/10
Total: __/20