Religion in the United States

Learning outcomes

  • Describe current U.S. trends including megachurches and secularization
  • Give examples of religion as an agent of social change

In examining the state of religion in the United States today, we see the complexity of religious life in our society, plus emerging trends like the rise of the megachurch, secularization, and the role of religion in social change.

A stadium is full of people. In the background, central point in the picture there is a large screen which projects the images of people on stage, similar to a stadium music concert.

Figure 1. Lakewood church in Houston, Texas holds a service in a former sports arena which seats 16,000 people. (Photo courtesy of ToBeDaniel/Wikimedia Commons)

U.S. Trends in Religion

Megachurches

A megachurch is a Christian church that has a very large congregation averaging more than 2,000 people who attend regular weekly services. As of 2016, the largest megachurches in the United States were the Lakewood Church in Houston Texas, with an average weekly attendance of more than 43,500, and Life.Church in Edmond, Oklahoma, with up to 53,000 weekly attendees. Megachurches have existed in other parts of the world, especially South Korea, Brazil, and several African countries, but the rise of the megachurch in the United States is a fairly recent phenomenon that has developed primarily in California, Florida, Georgia, and Texas.

Since 1970 the number of megachurches in the United States has grown from about fifty to more than 1,000, most of which are affiliated with the Southern Baptist denomination (Bogan, 2009). Approximately six million people are members of these churches (Bird and Thumma, 2011). The architecture of these church buildings often resembles a sports arena or concert hall more than it does a traditional site of religious worship. The church may include jumbotrons (large-screen televisions typically used in sports arenas to show close-ups of an event). Worship services may feature contemporary music with drums and electric guitars and use state-of-the-art sound equipment. The buildings sometimes include food courts, sports and recreation facilities, and bookstores. Services such as child care and mental health counseling are often offered.

Typically, a single charismatic pastor leads the megachurch; at present, all are male. Some megachurches and their celebrity preachers have a wide-ranging television presence, and viewers all around the country watch and respond to their performances and frequent fundraising drives.

Chart titled "Changing U.S. Religious Landscape" showing from 2007 to 2014, a 0.9% decline in Evangelical Protestantism, a 3.1% decline in Catholicism, a 3.4% decline in mainline Protestantism, a 1.2% rise in non-Christian faiths, and a 6.7% rise in unaffiliated.

Figure 2. Christianity is declining in the United States, while those claiming to be unaffiliated or in non-Christian faiths is rising.

Besides size, United States megachurches share other traits, including conservative theology, evangelism, use of technology and social networking (Facebook, Twitter, podcasts, blogs), charismatic leaders, successful fundraising, multiple sites, and a predominantly white membership. They list their main focuses as youth activities, community service, and study of Scripture (Hartford Institute for Religion Research b).

Critics of megachurches believe they are too large to promote close relationships among fellow church members or with the pastor, such as those that might occur in smaller houses of worship. Supporters note that, in addition to the large worship services, congregations may also meet in small groups, and some megachurches have informal events throughout the week to allow for community-building (Hartford Institute for Religion Research a).

Secularization

August Comte, Émile Durkheim, Max Weber, and Karl Marx predicted that in modern society, positivism (Comte’s term), rationality (Weber’s term), and science would displace the religious perspectives from earlier societies. Weber believed membership in distinguished clubs would outpace membership in Protestant sects as a way for people to gain authority or respect, but this has not come to fruition. In our modern, scientific world, traditional religious values still play an important role, sometimes conflicting with scientific views and other times adjusting because of them, or supporting them. Some of the high-profile confrontations between leaders of religious and scientific communities over issues such as embryonic stem cells, genetic modification, and family planning illustrate that science has not simply replaced religion in the modern world [1]

Secularization is the decline in the social and cultural importance of religion. As discussed in previous sections, secularization has also been imposed in some areas of the world, as in China following its communist takeover in 1949. Some people suggest secularization is a root cause of many social problems, such as divorce, drug use, and educational downturn. One-time presidential contender Michele Bachmann even linked Hurricane Irene and the 2011 earthquake felt in Washington D.C. to politicians’ failure to listen to God (Ward, 2011).

While some scholars see the United States becoming increasingly secular, others observe a rise in fundamentalism, which is defined as belief in the unquestionable authority of sacred texts and/or religious leaders. Christian fundamentalists, for example, often claim that the events and descriptions in the Bible are true in a literal and material sense. Secularization interests social observers because it entails a pattern of change in a fundamental social institution. Compared to other democratic, industrialized countries, the United States is generally perceived to be a fairly religious nation. Whereas 65 percent of U.S. adults in a 2009 Gallup survey said religion was an important part of their daily lives, the numbers were lower in Spain (49 percent), Canada (42 percent), France (30 percent), the United Kingdom (27 percent), and Sweden (17 percent) (Crabtree and Pelham, 2009). These numbers do seem to be declining as secularization or non-religious affiliation increases.

Watch this video of sociologist Peter Kivisto as he explains the sociology of religion, and particularly how religion is changing through secularization. He reviews some of the ideas from key theorists and examines how and why secularization has not happened as much as some early sociologists predicted.

Link to Learning

Check out the 20 most religious countries in the world and the 20 least religious countries in the world. Are you surprised by any of the rankings? Why?

Thank God for that Touchdown: Separation of Church and State

Imagine three public universities with football games scheduled on Saturday. At University A, a group of students in the stands who share the same faith decide to form a circle amid the spectators to pray for the team. For fifteen minutes, people in the circle share their prayers aloud among their group. At University B, the team ahead at halftime decides to join together in prayer, giving thanks and seeking support from God. This lasts for the first ten minutes of halftime on the sidelines of the field while spectators watch. At University C, the game program includes, among its opening moments, two minutes set aside for the team captain to share a prayer of his choosing with the spectators.

In the tricky area of separation of church and state, which of these actions is allowed and which is forbidden? In our three fictional scenarios, the last example is against the law while the first two situations are perfectly acceptable.

In the United States, a nation founded on the principles of religious freedom (many settlers were escaping religious persecution in Europe), how stringently do we adhere to this ideal? How well do we respect people’s right to practice any belief system of their choosing? The answer just might depend on what religion you practice.

In 2003, for example, a lawsuit escalated in Alabama regarding a monument to the Ten Commandments in a public building. This led to a 2018 state amendment that voters passed which explicitly allows for the display of the Ten Commandments in public places. The Arkansas American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a lawsuit in 2018, seeking to have a Ten Commandments monument removed from the Arkansas State Capitol. The plaintiffs in these cases argue that any state-sanctioned recognition of religion suggests endorsement of one belief system at the expense of all others—contradictory to the idea of freedom of religion. A similar case in New Mexico resulted in the City of Bloomfield relocating its Ten Commandments monument from the front lawn of City Hall to a private property at a nearby church.  

So what violates separation of church and state and what is acceptable? When it comes to Ten Commandment monuments on government property, it seems that if there are other monuments representing beliefs and values, it is not a violation of the First Amendment; however, if the monument stands on its own and is reasonably assumed to show preference or endorsement for one particular religious view, it is unconstitutional.

Watch the short video clip below and think about what sociological variables can influence religiosity in the U.S. and around the world:

Think It Over

  • Do you believe the United States is becoming more secularized or more fundamentalist?
  • Comparing your generation to that of your parents or grandparents, what differences do you see in the relationship between religion and society
  • What would popular media have you believe is the state of religion in the United States today?

Religion and Social Change

Religion has historically been an impetus for social change. The translation of sacred texts into everyday, non-scholarly language empowered people to shape their religions. The United States is no stranger to religion as an agent of social change. In fact, some of the first colonial settlers in what would become the United States were acting on religious convictions when they crossed the Atlantic and made their way to the New World.

Disagreements between religious groups and instances of religious persecution have led to wars and genocides—the very same European settlers that came to the New World looking for religious freedom persecuted Native Americans, forced conversions and family separation, and used religion to justify the practice of human slavery.

Liberation Theology

Liberation theology began as a movement within the Roman Catholic Church in the 1950s and 1960s in Latin America. Liberation theology combines Christian principles with political activism; it is the synthesis of Christian theology and Marxist socio-economic principles, emphasizing liberation for oppressed peoples. It uses the church to promote social change via the political arena, and it is most often seen in attempts to reduce or eliminate social injustice, discrimination, and poverty. One of the founding members of the movement, Father Gustavo Gutiérrez Merino (a Peruvian theologian and Dominican priest) said true liberation has the following dimensions:

  • It addresses the elimination of the immediate causes of poverty and injustice with the goal of political and social liberation, 
  • It involves the the emancipation of the poor, the marginalized, or the oppressed and the removal of obstacles limiting their ability to develop with dignity 
  • It involves liberation from selfishness and sin as well as a re-establishment of a relationship with God and with other people. 

Civil wars and political unrest in Latin America in the 1970s and 1980s led to the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of people, including priests. One of these priests was the Archbishop Oscar Romero, who was killed in 1980 by a Salvadoran death squad, shortly after he asked the soldiers to stop killing each other. Romero was canonized in 2018 by Pope Francis.[2].

Although begun as a moral reaction against the poverty caused by social injustice in that part of the world, today liberation theology is an international movement that encompasses many churches and denominations, such as Jewish liberation or black liberation philosophy. Liberation theologians discuss theology from the point of view of the poor and the oppressed, and some interpret the scriptures as a call to action against poverty and injustice. In Europe and North America, feminist theology has emerged from liberation theology as a movement to bring social justice to women.

Liberation theology influences Pope Francis’ philosophy from the Vatican today, as demonstrated by his pointed critiques of economic exploitation. In Pope Francis’ first apostolic exhortation, Evangelii gaudium (The Joy of the Gospel), he said, “Today we also have to say ‘Thou shalt not’ to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills.” [3]

Religion and Gay Pride

What happens when a religious leader officiates a gay marriage against denomination policies? What about when that same minister defends the action in part by coming out and making her own lesbian relationship known to the church?

In the case of the Reverend Amy DeLong, it meant a church trial. Some leaders in her denomination assert that homosexuality is incompatible with their faith, while others feel this type of discrimination has no place in a modern church (Barrick, 2011). As the LBGTQ+ community increasingly advocates for, and earns, basic civil rights, how will religious communities respond? Many religious groups have traditionally discounted LBGTQ+ sexualities as “wrong.” However, these organizations have moved closer to respecting human rights by, for example, increasingly recognizing females as an equal gender.

Pope Francis, current head of the Catholic Church, has said that homosexual tendencies “are not a sin” and famously queried, “Who am I to judge?” Pope Francis was also the first pope to use the word “gay” in 2013. He also said no parent should throw a homosexual son or daughter out of their home [4]. This has resulted in a renewed conversation about homosexuality among the world’s Catholics, and among other religious denominations.

Link to Learning

Visit the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, a research institute examining U.S. and world religious trends, to learn more about religion and how it’s practiced.

Watch It

Watch this TEDTalk about Megan Phelps-Roper’s experience growing up in the controversial Westboro Baptist Church (WBC) and how and why she decided to leave the religious group. The WBC describes itself as “Primitive Baptist” that follows the five points of Calvinism, but it has been classified as a hate group, known for holding extreme views and for loudly picketing against homosexuality, Jews, the military, and other groups. 

glossary

liberation theology:
the use of a church to promote social change via the political arena
megachurch:
a Christian church that has a very large congregation averaging more than 2,000 people who attend regular weekly services
secularization:
the historical decline in the and social and cultural importance of religion, religiosity, and sacred practices and beliefs

  1. Evans 2010; Nelkin 2004 as quoted in "Traditional, Modern, and Post-Secular Perspectives on Science and Religion in the United States" by Timothy L. O'Brien and Shiri Roy in The American Sociological Review, 2015. http://www.asanet.org/sites/default/files/savvy/journals/ASR/Feb15ASRFeature2.pdf
  2. "Archbishop Oscar Romero," Liberation Theologies Online Library and Reference Center. https://liberationtheology.org/people-organizations/oscar-romero/.
  3. Stephenson, Wen. 2015. "How Pope Francis Came to Embrace..." The Nation. https://www.thenation.com/article/how-pope-francis-came-to-embrace-not-just-climate-justice-but-liberation-theology/.
  4. San Martin, Ines. 2019. "Pope Says Homosexual Tendencies..." https://cruxnow.com/vatican/2019/04/01/pope-francis-says-homosexual-tendencies-are-not-a-sin/.