- Describe viewpoints from the major psychological perspectives related to the etiology of personality disorders
A Historical Understanding of Personality Disorders
As you have learned in this module, the DSM-5 defines personality disorders as “an enduring pattern of inner experience and behavior that deviates markedly from the expectations of the individual’s culture, is pervasive and inflexible, has an onset in adolescence or early adulthood, is stable over time, and leads to distress or impairment.” This definition has evolved over time.
The consideration of cultural context is perhaps the most significant change in this definition from the earlier DSM-3. Although the DSM-4-TR made a point of adding cultural context to the definition of personality disorders, it wasn’t until the publication of the DSM-5 that much was said in the manual about culture. Not only is there limited research regarding the influence of culture on personality disorders, there is likewise only limited research on cultural influences on normal personality.
Currently, genetic research for the understanding of the development of personality disorders is severely lacking. However, there are a few possible risk factors currently in discovery. Researchers are currently looking into genetic mechanisms for traits such as aggression, fear, and anxiety, which are associated with diagnosed individuals. More research is being conducted into disorder-specific mechanisms.
There are some genetic factors connected to biological or genetic components, but no specific mechanisms have been identified. This means that there is likely a biological predisposition for some personality disorders, but more research needs to be done to determine the precise connections.
The psychodynamic theory on personality proposes events that happen to us in our childhood impacts our lives as we mature. Even if childhood events remain in our unconscious, significant problems may arise with our personalities in adolescence and adulthood. Psychodynamic theory views personality as exhibited behaviors and characteristics caused by unconscious factors that we do not have control over.
Cognitive theorists propose a link between personality and disruptive and disordered thought patterns. Individuals with a personality disorder may develop inaccurate perceptions of others (Beck, 2015). There may be a relationship between biological factors and adverse environmental factors. Disordered patterns of perceiving and relating to the world may develop as protective measures during childhood. These patterns of behavior may be reflected as characteristics of a personality disorder.
Behavioral theorists believe people behave in a consistent manner and view personality as being shaped by reinforcements and consequences. We learn to behave in certain ways, increasing behaviors that lead to positive consequences and decreasing behaviors that lead to negative outcomes. We have to consider modeling, reinforcement, and the inability to develop normal social skills. In modeling, an individual may learn dysfunctional social patterns and behaviors by directly observing family members engaging in similar behaviors. With reinforcement, individuals may be rewarded by gaining their desired outcomes when they successfully manipulate others. Additionally, when there is exaggerated praise, individuals may develop a grandiose sense of self, similar to a narcissistic personality (Millon, 2011).
Although genetic studies on personality disorders are relatively rare, many researchers agree avoiding certain social situations may contribute to the development of personality disorders. It’s not clear if lacking social skills leads to the avoidance of social settings or if lacking social skills develops as a result of avoiding social situations (APA, 2013).
We also have to consider how life experiences factor into the development of personality disorders. Trauma and abuse play key roles in possible causes of the ten personality disorders.
Child abuse and neglect consistently show up as risk factors to the development of personality disorders in adulthood. A study looked at retrospective reports of abuse of participants that had demonstrated psychopathology throughout their life and were later found to have past experience with abuse. In a study of 793 mothers and children, researchers asked mothers if they had screamed at their children, told them that they did not love them, or threatened to send them away. Children who had experienced such verbal abuse were three times as likely as other children (who did not experience such verbal abuse) to have borderline, narcissistic, obsessive-compulsive, or paranoid personality disorders in adulthood. The sexually abused group demonstrated the most consistently elevated patterns of psychopathology. Officially verified physical abuse showed an extremely strong correlation with the development of antisocial and impulsive behavior.
Socioeconomic status has also been looked at as a potential cause for personality disorders. There is a strong association between low parental/neighborhood socioeconomic status and personality disorder symptoms. In a recent study comparing parental SES and a child’s personality, it was seen that children who were from higher socioeconomic backgrounds were more altruistic, less risk-seeking, and had overall higher IQs. A study looking at female children who were detained for disciplinary actions found that psychological problems were most negatively associated with socioeconomic problems.
Evidence shows personality disorders may begin with parental personality issues. These cause the parent to have their own difficulties in adulthood, such as difficulties reaching higher education, obtaining jobs, and securing dependable relationships. By either genetic or modeling mechanisms, children can pick up these traits. Additionally, poor parenting appears to have symptom elevating effects on personality disorders. More specifically, lack of maternal bonding has also been correlated with personality disorders. In a study comparing 100 healthy individuals to 100 borderline personality disorder patients, analysis showed that BPD patients were significantly more likely not to have been breastfed as a baby (42.4% in BPD vs. 9.2% in healthy controls). These researchers suggested this act may be essential in fostering maternal relationships. When left unfostered, other attachment and interpersonal problems occur later in life ultimately leading to the development of personality disorders.
Key Takeaways: The Etiology of Personality Disorders
- Biological causes of personality disorders have not been identified for most disorders. It is difficult to determine whether genetics play a significant role in the development of personality disorders to the exclusion of social and psychological factors.
- Psychological causes of personality disorders include negative early childhood experiences, maladaptive thought patterns, cognitive distortions, modeling, reinforcement, and lack of social skills.
- Social causes of personality disorders include high levels of psychological and social dysfunction within families and maltreatment.
- "What Causes Psychological Disorders?". American Psychological Association. 2010. Archived from the original on 20 November 2010. ↵
- Deckers, Thomas (February 2015). "How does Socio-Economic Status Shape a Child's Personality?" (PDF). Human Capital and Economic Opportunity Global Working Group. ↵
- Schwarze, Cornelia E.; Hellhammer, Dirk H.; Stroehle, Verena; Lieb, Klaus; Mobascher, Arian (23 September 2014). "Lack of Breastfeeding: A Potential Risk Factor in the Multifactorial Genesis of Borderline Personality Disorder and Impaired Maternal Bonding". Journal of Personality Disorders. 29 (5): 610–26. doi:10.1521/pedi_2014_28_160. ISSN 0885-579X. PMID 25248013. ↵